CNCTR Annual Report 2023
Full title in original language
Rapport annuel 2023 de la CNCTR
Reports
CNCTR Annual Report 2022
Document contents
.....................37 2.1.1 Le nombre de contrôles réalisés en 2022 : des marges de progression limitées en l’état..................................38 3 2.1.2 Les irrégularités relevées
Reports
Report on the activity of the Parliamentary Delegation for Intelligence for the year 2021-2022
Full title in original language
Rapport relatif à l’activité de la délégation parlementaire au renseignement pour l’année 2021-2022
Reports
CNCTR Annual Report 2021
Document contents
travail afin de faciliter et améliorer l’efficacité de son contrôle. Les marges de progression dans ce domaine se révèlent aujourd’hui limitées. En outre, les défis
Reports
Report on the activity of the Parliamentary Delegation for Intelligence for the year 2020-2021
Full title in original language
Rapport relatif à l’activité de la délégation parlementaire au renseignement pour l’année 2020-2021
Reports
Bill on the Prevention of Terrorism and Intelligence
Full title in original language
Loi n°2021-998 du 30 juillet 2021 relative à la prévention d’actes de terrorisme et au renseignement
Laws and regulation
Impact Study of the Bill on the Prevention of Terrorism and Intelligence
Document contents
et juger, au même moment que celui du sommet, les infractions commises en marge du sommet du G7 et de son contre-sommet. Le juge des référés a estimé
Reports
Big Brother Watch and others v. United Kingdom (Grand Chamber Judgment)
Document contents
Fridrik Kjølbro, Angelika Nußberger, Paul Lemmens, Yonko Grozev, Vincent A. De Gaetano, Paulo Pinto de Albuquerque, Faris Vehabović, Iulia Antoanella Motoc, Carlo Ranzoni, Mārtiņš Mits
Case law
Schrems II Judgment
Document contents
Digitaleurope, THE COURT (Grand Chamber), composed of K. Lenaerts, President, R. Silva de Lapuerta, Vice-President, A. Arabadjiev, A. Prechal, M. Vilaras, M. Safjan, S. Rodin, P
Case law
Surveillance by intelligence services: fundamental rights safeguards and remedies in the EU Volume II: field perspectives and legal update
Document contents
Serviço de Informações de Segurança e do Serviço de Informações Estratégicas de Defesa e procede à segunda alteração à Lei n.º 62/2013, de 26 de Agosto
Reports
Deliberation on the 2021 Intelligence Bill
Full title in original language
loi relatif a la prévention d'actes de terrorisme et au renseignement
Reports
Deliberation on the 2021 Intelligence Bill - update on data retention rulings
Full title in original language
loi relatif a la prévention d'actes de terrorisme et au renseignement
Reports
Report of the Bulk Powers Review
Document contents
exercise had been performed, adding that there should be no question of progressing proposals for the compulsory retention of third party data before such time
Reports
CNCTR Annual Report 2020
Document contents
titre de la surveillance internationale : une augmentation témoignant de l’appropriation progressive par les services de renseignement des dispositions législatives introduites en 2018........
Reports
Bill on the Prevention of Terrorism and on Intelligence
Full title in original language
Projet de loi relatif à la prévention du terrorisme et au renseignement
Laws and regulation
White Paper on Internal Security
Full title in original language
Livre blanc de la sécurité interieure
Reports
Report on Surveillance Systems That Might Undermine National Security
Full title in original language
Rapport d'information sur les systèmes de surveillance et d'interception électroniques pouvant mettre
Reports
Centrum för Rättvisa v. Sweden (Grand Chamber Judgment)
Document contents
Fridrik Kjølbro, Angelika Nußberger, Paul Lemmens, Yonko Grozev, Vincent A. De Gaetano, Paulo Pinto de Albuquerque, Faris Vehabović, Iulia Antoanella Motoc, Carlo Ranzoni, Mārtiņš Mits
Case law
Convention 108 + Convention for the protection of individuals with regard to the processing of personal data
Document contents
Europe French edition: Convention 108+ Convention pour la protection des personnes à l’égard du traitement des données à caractère personnel All requests concerning the reproduction
Laws and regulation
Investigatory Powers Commissioner's Office 2019 Annual Report
Document contents
Zealand (London) 4 September meeting with the Commission Nationale de Contrôle des Techniques de Renseignement (Paris, France) 8-9 October UN International Intelligence
Reports
Privacy International v Investigatory Powers Tribunal & Ors
Document contents
the reasons for the delay in raising this ground by reference to the progress of the Claimant’s various challenges both in the domestic courts and in
Case law
La Quadrature du Net and Others v Premier Ministre and Others
Document contents
2015 relatif au contentieux de la mise en œuvre des techniques de renseignement soumises à autorisation et des fichiers intéressant la sûreté de l’État (Decree No 2015‑1211
Case law
Privacy International v Secretary of State
Document contents
French Government, initially by E. de Moustier, E. Armoët, A.-L. Desjonquères, F. Alabrune, D. Colas and D. Dubois, and subsequently by E. de Moustier, E. Armoët, A.-L. Desjonquères
Case law
Report on Use of Selectors for NSA Inquiry Committee
Document contents
wird in der ersten Stufe nach Top-Level-Domains (TLD) gefiltert. Neben der TLD .de werden auch neuere TLD, wie beispielsweise .bayern geprüft. Auf der zweiten Stufe
Reports
Draft Bill of BND Law 2020/2021
Document contents
forwarded pursuant to paragraph 3. The Federal Chancellery submits an annual progress report to the Parliamentary Oversight Panel on the extent to which the
Laws and regulation
Belhaj and ors v SSHD and ors (No 4)
Document contents
consideration of (in particular) Article 8 for a conclusion that an interference is de minimis: Mr Eadie refers to M v Secretary of State for Work & Pensions [2006]
Case law
R Bridge v CC South Wales and ors (High Court)
Document contents
AFR Locate which has been in progress since April 2017, and which remains in progress. We accept that, as the trial progresses, it is likely that these
Case law
R Bridges v CC South Wales and ors (Court of Appeal)
Document contents
liberties membership organisation. The Respondent is the Chief Constable of SWP (Heddlu De Cymru). 5. The Interested Party, the Secretary of State for the Home Department,
Case law
Watson and ors v SSHD and ors (Court of Appeal)
Document contents
Iain Steele (instructed by Liberty) for the First Respondent Richard Drabble QC, Ramby De Mello and Azeem Suterwalla (instructed by Bhatia Best Solicitors) for the Second and
Case law
Watson and ors v SSHD and ors (High Court)
Document contents
by Liberty) for the Claimants Mr Davis and Mr Watson Richard Drabble QC, Ramby de Mello, Azeem Suterwalla and James Dixon (instructed by Bhatia Best) for the Claimants
Case law
Privacy International v SSFCA and ors (No 5)
Document contents
SECURITY SERVICE (5) SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE Claimant Respondents --------------------Mr T De La Mare QC, Mr B Jaffey QC and Mr D Cashman (instructed by Bhatt Murphy
Case law
Privacy International v SSFCA and ors (No 3)
Document contents
date: 1 December 2017 --------------------- Page 1 Claimant Respondents APPEARANCES Mr T De La Mare QC, Mr B Jaffey QC and Mr D Cashman (instructed by Bhatt Murphy
Case law
Privacy International v SSFCA and ors (No 2)
Document contents
6, 8 and 9 June 2017 --------------------- Claimant Respondents APPEARANCES Mr T De La Mare QC, Mr B Jaffey QC and Mr D Cashman (instructed by Bhatt Murphy
Case law
Privacy International v SSFCA and ors (No 1)
Document contents
SERVICE Respondents __________ __________ 1 A PPEA R A N C E S MR. T. DE LA MARE QC, MR. B. JAFFEY and MR. D. CASHMAN (instructed by Bhatt Murphy Solicitors)
Case law
Report on the activity of the Parliamentary Delegation for Intelligence for the year 2019-2020
Full title in original language
Rapport relatif à l'activité de la délégation parlementaire au renseignement pour l'année 2019
Reports
Privacy International v United Kingdom
Document contents
providing Internet services and communications services respectively. The sixth applicant, Korean Progressive Network Jinbonet, is an Internet service provider registered in South Korea. 4. The
Case law
Zakharov v Russia
Document contents
to be lodged, with the result that counter-intelligence-related surveillance measures de facto escaped any supervision by prosecutors. It was also significant that prosecutors
Case law
Leander v Sweden
Document contents
CONSEIL DE L’EUROPE COUNCIL OF EUROPE COUR EUROPÉENNE DES DROITS DE L’HOMME EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS COURT (CHAMBER) CASE OF LEANDER v. SWEDEN (Application no. 9248/81)
Case law
Liberty v United Kingdom
Document contents
CONSEIL DE L’EUROPE COUNCIL OF EUROPE COUR EUROPÉENNE DES DROITS DE L’HOMME EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS FOURTH SECTION CASE OF LIBERTY AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED
Case law
Weber and Saravia v Germany
Document contents
CONSEIL DE L’EUROPE COUNCIL OF EUROPE COUR EUROPÉENNE DES DROITS DE L’HOMME EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS THIRD SECTION DECISION AS TO THE ADMISSIBILITY OF Application
Case law
Silver v United Kingdom
Document contents
CONSEIL DE L’EUROPE COUNCIL OF EUROPE COUR EUROPÉENNE DES DROITS DE L’HOMME EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS COURT (CHAMBER) CASE OF SILVER AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED
Case law
Malone v United Kingdom
Document contents
CONSEIL DE L’EUROPE COUNCIL OF EUROPE COUR EUROPÉENNE DES DROITS DE L’HOMME EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS COURT (PLENARY) CASE OF MALONE v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application
Case law
Klass v Germany
Document contents
CONSEIL DE L’EUROPE COUNCIL OF EUROPE COUR EUROPÉENNE DES DROITS DE L’HOMME EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS COURT (PLENARY) CASE OF KLASS AND OTHERS v. GERMANY (Application
Case law
Release of NSA selector lists to G10 Commission
Document contents
Vorsitzenden, Platz der Republik 1, 11011 Berlin, - Bevollmächtigter: Rechtsanwalt Dr. Hans de With, Frutolfstraße 26 b, 96049 Bamberg Antragsgegner: 1. Bundesregierung der Bundesrepublik
Case law
Release of NSA selector lists to NSA Inquiry Committee
Document contents
Maidowski 24/25 Bundesverfassungsgericht, Beschluss des Zweiten Senats vom 13. Oktober 2016 2 BvE 2/15 Zitiervorschlag BVerfG, Beschluss des Zweiten Senats vom 13. Oktober 2016
Case law
G10 Law (Judgment)
Document contents
nahm GG 2. Die Art. 10 Be A im einze 1. F?r die Zul?s behaupte Ma?nahmen de die Zahl Gesetzes zu A f?r den B?rger darleg deskanz durch die Ano ?berwac gung
Case law
Fundamental right to integrity and confidentiality of IT systems
Document contents
333 Bundesverfassungsgericht, Urteil des Ersten Senats vom 27. Februar 2008 1 BvR 370/07, 1 BvR 595/07 Zitiervorschlag BVerfG, Urteil des Ersten Senats vom 27. Februar
Case law
Electronic profile-searching I
Document contents
Bundesverfassungsgericht, Beschluss des Ersten Senats vom 14. Juli 1999 1 BvR 2226/94, 1 BvR 2437/95, 1 BvR 2420/95 Zitiervorschlag BVerfG, Beschluss des Ersten Senats vom
Case law
BND Law (Judgment)
Document contents
respect of France: Article L854-1 to L854-9 Code de la sécurité intérieure [Des mesures de surveillance des communications électroniques internationales]; cf. Le Divelec,
Case law
Automated lincence plate control in Bavaria
Document contents
33/34 176 Bundesverfassungsgericht, Beschluss des Ersten Senats vom 18. Dezember 2018 1 BvR 142/15 Zitiervorschlag BVerfG, Beschluss des Ersten Senats vom 18. Dezember 2018
Case law
Act Approving the Convention on Cybercrime
Document contents
Hoheitsgebieten festgelegt werden müssen. Dem Grundsatz der Zweckbindung wer- 7 11/30 de in keiner Weise Rechnung getragen, da nach Art. 32 CCC erhobene Daten uneingeschränkt
Case law
BKA Law
Document contents
Bundesverfassungsgericht, Urteil des Ersten Senats vom 20. April 2016 - 1 BvR 966/ 09, 1 BvR 1140/09 Zitiervorschlag BVerfG, Urteil des Ersten Senats vom 20.
Case law
Anti Terrorism Database I
Document contents
44/45 233 Bundesverfassungsgericht, Urteil des Ersten Senats vom 24. April 2013 1 BvR 1215/07 Zitiervorschlag BVerfG, Urteil des Ersten Senats vom 24. April 2013
Case law
Access to information on inventory data II
Document contents
Diese läge den Sicherheitsbehörden häufig nicht vor und wer- 42 30/92 de von den Providern nicht zuverlässig gespeichert. Obgleich bei dem IPv6 nicht mehr
Case law
Access to information on inventory data I
Document contents
events in the internet are de-anonymised not only for a limited period of time, but permanently. Such a far-reaching possibility of de-anonymisation of communication
Case law
Data retention
Document contents
Duties Act and the Parliamentary Control Panel Act (Gesetz zur Änderung des Polizeiaufgabengesetzes und des Parlamentarischen Kontrollgremium-Gesetzes ) of 24 December 2005 (Bavarian Law
Case law
The BND's obligation to provide infromation on meetings for journalists
Document contents
3 Nr. 8 IFG vorgesehenen Ausschluss eines Informationszugangs anerkannt werden, ist de lege lata nicht gerechtfertigt. Der Senat hat sich schon bisher gegen die
Case law
Strategic surveillance by the BND after 9 11
Document contents
Voraussetzungen gehöre insbesondere, dass nur Nachrichten über Sachverhalte gesammelt werden dürften, de- - 18 - ren Kenntnis zur rechtzeitigen Erkennung der Gefahrenlagen notwendig
Case law
Storage and use of telecommunication metadata by the BND
Document contents
2014 der nach Art. 29 der Richtlinie 95/46/EG eingesetzten Datenschutzgruppe, 0829/14/DE WP216). Aufgehoben werden kann der durch die nachrichtendienstliche Datenerhebung begründete
Case law
BND’s surveillance programme for bulk collection of e-mail traffic
Document contents
G 10, Gesetz zur Code of Administrative Court Procedure VwGO, Grundgesetz Beschränkung des Brief-, Postund Fernmeldegeheimnisses – Gesetz zu Artikel article 1 (1), article 2 (1)
Case law
Obligation of a telecommunications provider to cooperate on foreign telecommunications surveillance
Plaintiff
DE-CIX Management GmbH
Case law
Report of the German Parliament on the effects of Fight Against Terrorism Act 2017
Document contents
15(4)218. Der Bericht ist darüber hinaus online abrufbar unter: https://www.bmi.bund.de/SharedDocs/Downloads/DE/Themen/Sicherheit/Terrorismus/Bericht_BReg_Auswirkung_Terrorismusbekaempfungsgesetz.pdf?__blob=publicationFile (zuletzt abgerufen am
Reports
Report of the German Parliament on the effects of Fight Against Terrorism Act 2015
Document contents
15(4)218. Der Bericht ist darüber hinaus online abrufbar unter: https://www.bmi.bund.de/SharedDocs/Downloads/DE/Themen/Sicherheit/Terrorismus/Bericht_BReg_Auswirkung_Terrorismusbekaempfungsgesetz.pdf?__blob=publicationFile (zuletzt abgerufen am
Reports
Investigatory Powers Commissioner's Office 2018 Annual Report
Document contents
Commission Nationale de Contrôles des Techniques de Renseignement (CNCTR) and the Belgian Comité Permanent de Contrôle des Services de Renseignement et de Sécurité (CPR)
Reports
Investigatory Powers Commissioner's Office 2017 Annual Report
Document contents
problem experienced across government but as a result of the notably slow progress – this regularly takes well in excess of nine months – a significant
Reports
Interception of Communications Commissioner 2016 Annual Report
Document contents
include the following: A review of recommendations from the previous inspection and progress towards their implementation. An audit of the requests that public authorities
Reports
Interception of Communications Commissioner 2015 Annual Report
Document contents
At the point at which this report was finished, the IP Bill had progressed to the House of Lords. The comments in the following paragraphs relate
Reports
Interception of Communications Commissioner 2014 Annual Report
Document contents
interception agency or WGD to inform my office within two months on what progress has been made. The inspection reports contain operational detail which, under
Reports
Interception of Communications Commissioner 2013 Annual Report
Document contents
two months to say that the recommendations have been implemented, or what progress has been made. These are sensitive documents, but, speaking generally, they contain:
Reports
Interception of Communications Commissioner 2012 Annual Report
Document contents
prescribed time period, that the recommendations have been implemented or outline the progress they have made to achieve the recommendations. 7.3 Communications Data Requests
Reports
Interception of Communications Commissioner 2011 Annual Report
Document contents
on all communications addresses covered by the warrant. The number was immediately de-tasked and an investigation initiated into any wider discrepancies between targeting
Reports
Interception of Communications Commissioner 2010 Annual Report
Document contents
include the following: A review of recommendations from the previous inspection and progress towards their implementation. An audit of the requests that public authorities
Reports
Interception of Communications Commissioner 2009 Annual Report
Document contents
of continuity to re-state the background to this issue again before reporting on progress. 2.7 In my Reports I commented on the statement made by the Prime Minister
Reports
Interception of Communications Commissioner 2008 Annual Report
Document contents
light of the Strasbourg judgment. I hope to be able to report on the progress of this consideration in my 2009 Annual Report. Briefing by the National
Reports
Democratic License to Operate
Document contents
Court of Justice, ‘Google Spain SL, Google Inc. v. Agencia Española de Protección de Datos (AEPD), Mario Costeja González’, C-131/12 ruling, point 2. 11. Correct
Reports
A Question of Trust (David Anderson)
Document contents
Matthias Reute, DG Home, Director General Gilles de Kerkhove, Counter-Terrorism Coordinator Stefano Manservisi, Chef de Cabinet of High Representative Mogherini Giovanni
Reports
ISC Report on Women in the UK Intelligence Community
Document contents
different solutions, and this competition, collaboration and challenge is essential to making progress. Organisations have moved on from the dreary mandatory half-day training courses to
Reports
Resolution on Implementation of the Committee of Inquiry on NSA
Document contents
Missstände geklagt. Das ist eine schallende Ohrfeige für den abgetretenen Verteidigungsminister de Maizière. Ich füge hinzu: Die ersten Initiativen von Frau von der Leyen lassen
Reports
Committee of Inquiry on NSA Special Vote DIE LINKE
Document contents
als Urkundenunterdrückung (§274 StGB) und Verwahrungsbruch (§133 StGB). Bundesinnenminister Thomas de Maizière (CDU) und Dr. Hans-Georg Maaßen tragen die Verantwortung dafür, dass dem Unte
Reports
PKGr Special Review Report 2017
Document contents
März 2017, S. 8, 40; siehe auch zugehörige Chronologie S. 7 [https://mbem.nrw/de/node/4138 ]). Das Gespräch führte AMRI im Chatprogramm Telegram unter libyschen Telefonnummern
Reports
PKGr Special Review Report 2015
Document contents
Personen im Rahmen ihres Einsatzes Straftaten begehen dürfen. Die Rechtslage scheint de lege lata nach einem entsprechenden Urteil des OLG Düsseldorf klar zu sein.
Reports
PKGr Report on the effects of Fight Against Terrorism Act 2013
Document contents
Parlamentarische Kontrollgremium der 17. Wahlperiode bestellte am 27. Januar 2010 Dr. Hans de With (Vorsitzender), Erwin Marschewski (Stellvertretender Vorsitzender), Rainer Funke und Ulrich
Reports
PKGr Report on the effects of Fight Against Terrorism Act 2012
Document contents
Wahlperiode endet. Das Parlamentarische Kontrollgremium bestellte am 27. Januar 2010 Dr. Hans de With (Vorsitzender), Erwin Marschewski (Stellvertretender Vorsitzender), Rainer Funke und Ulrich
Reports
PKGr Report on the effects of Fight Against Terrorism Act 2003
Document contents
stellvertretende Mitglieder folgende Personen benannt: Mitglieder stellvertretende Mitglieder Dr. Hans de With (Vorsitzender) Prof. Dr. Heinz Gester Erwin Marschewski, MdB Rudolf Kraus, MdB
Reports
BfDI Annual Report on Freedom of Information 2018-2019
Document contents
des Referates von Prof. Dr. Pablo Contreras Vasquez vom Consejo de Transparencia in Santiago de Chile. Ein wesentlicher Anstoß für das südamerikanische Informationsfreiheitsrecht
Reports
BfDI Annual Report on Freedom of Information 2016-2017
Document contents
University School of Law und der HEC Paris (Ecole des Hautes Etudes Commerciales de Paris) getragen. Lehrer und ausgewählte Studenten beider Universitäten arbeiten zusammen
Reports
BfDI Annual Report on Freedom of Information 2014-2015
Document contents
derzeit (Stand Redaktionsschluss 31.12.2015) einen Zugang per De-Mail eingerichtet. Ein Lichtblick im Umgang mit der De-Mail ist die nun vereinfacht einsetzbare Ende-zu-Ende-Verschlüsselung
Reports
BfDI Annual Report on Freedom of Information 2012-2013
Document contents
im Bereich der Daseinsvorsorge, ins Netz stellten. Geodateninfrastruktur in Deutschland (GDI-DE) Bei Geodaten handelt es sich um Informationen mit Raumbezug. Sie bilden eine
Reports
BfDI Annual Report on Freedom of Information 2010-2011
Document contents
werden eben nicht in kleinen, hermetisch abgeschlossenen Zirkeln diskutiert und „per Ordre de Mufti“ entschieden, und das ist gut so! K a s t e n z u N r. 1
Reports
BfDI Annual Report on Freedom of Information 2008-2009
Document contents
Parlaments am 2. Juni 2008 geübt hat (Presseerklärung deutsch: http://ombudsman.europa.eu/release/de/2008-06-02.htm, Text der Stellungnahme nur englisch: http://www.om budsman.europa.eu/letters/en/20080526-1
Reports