APPEARANCES Mr T De La Mare QC, Mr B Jaffey QC and Mr D Cashman (instructed by Bhatt Murphy Solicitors) appeared on behalf of the Claimant Mr J Eadie QC, Mr A O'Connor QC, Mr G Facenna QC, Mr R Palmer and Mr R O'Brien (instructed by Government Legal Department) appeared on behalf of the Respondents Mr J Glasson QC (instructed by Government Legal Department) appeared as Counsel to the Tribunal --------------------- APPROVED JUDGMENT